I was very worried about the Bip's blue paint pick, but he sent me this photo, and it doesn't look too bad. Definitely going to give the house that lake-cottage feel once the trim is painted and all the decor is up, but it doesn't look horrible with the wood trim in the meantime, either.
Can't wait to get the curtains back up and the furniture back in it's proper places, etc.
EDIT: Spoke too soon. Not happy with any of the paint so far.